Contact Us
CALL US TODAY (608) 831-5656


Your Trusted Full Service Jeweler in Middleton, WI

Middleton Jewelers has consistently been offering superior buying, selling and trading services in the Middleton, WI area. Manny and Josh will help you find the perfect piece for a cherished loved one or a fantastic accessory for yourself. Gold, platinum, diamond and other precious metals and stones are all available to choose from designs and styles. You will always find exceptional value and friendly, helpful service for all your jewelry needs.

As a full service jeweler we buy, sell and trade all forms of jewelry, timepieces, gold, bullion, gemstones and more. You will always receive top dollar on your pieces at Middleton Jewelers. Our free estimates never require an obligation to buy or trade so you can be assured to receive a true value appraisal.

100% Trade Custom Jewelry Design that Can\’t be Beat

When you’re looking for that special piece Manny and Josh will guide you to the perfect item to match your style and budget. Our unbeatable prices on our high quality designs will assure your complete satisfaction. We even have the ability to customize any piece or work with your own design and replicate it.

We Buy at the Best Prices

We buy gold, silver, platinum and diamonds. Whatever your jewelry is worth, you can count on getting the best deal from us at Middleton Jewelers. Get cash for your gold at better rates than most others are paying. Or, if you prefer, you can use your jewelry items as a 100% trade-in on a custom design for yourself or a loved one. The condition of your items is of no concern. Jewelry, gold, stones and other precious commodities are valued based on weight and purity, not if they are broken or tarnished. Let us find the true value of your unused items.

Middleton Jewelers is on a mission to help you and your friends get the most for your gold, your old jewelry, silver, watches and diamonds. Times are tough so you may be looking for gold buying, selling or trading your belongings, but don’t know where to go or who to trust. We are here for you and will be every step of the way. Every sale carries the Middleton Jewelers “3P” customer standard.

PROFESSIONAL service you will rave about!
PRIVATE transactions.
PROFITABLE for you because your happiness is our most valuable asset!

Items we are looking to purchase:


Middleton Jewelers has combed the community for the best gemologists who have decades of experience who are ready to evaluate your diamonds TODAY! If you plan on bringing in your diamond please take pay attention to the next sentence:

Please note we are looking to purchase diamonds that are approximately 1 carat or larger. A certificate is a diamond grading report typically issued by one of two companies. The GIA (Gemological Institute of America) and the EGL (European Gemological Laboratory). These two organizations are the undisputed international authorities on diamond grading and gem identification.

When you bring in your diamonds a licensed gemologist will evaluate the piece(s) and then you will receive a quote. You can then choose to accept or decline our offer. If declined, Middleton Jewelers will give the item(s) back to you. If you accept the offer, a check will be cut and given to you.