Contact Us
CALL US TODAY (608) 831-5656


Fast and Accurate Jewelry Appraisals

When seeking an appraisal for your jewelry, you are looking for one important quality; honesty. At Middleton Jewelers, you can trust our jewelry appraisals to be accurate. You never have to leave our shop and go home wondering if you received fair value for your pieces. We are only interested in giving you the most accurate grading instead of under-valuing for profit.

Our Process

Each piece will be weighed accordingly using a calibrated Troy ounce scale and examined thoroughly with a jewelers loupe and gold test kit. Once we’ve accurately graded the metals purity we can separate them by karat and properly assess their monetary value.
You’re broken or worn jewelry is far more valuable then you may think. A piece is not assessed by its condition, but by its weight and purity. Bring us you’re unused or damaged jewelry and we can appraise it at its full value. Be sure not to disregard Estate Jewelry either, it can often be worth a lot more than you think.
You are never under any obligations with our appraisal service. At Middleton Jewelers we offer 100% on trade towards custom jewelry, so if you want to trade in your old for something new, let us know.

Full Service Jewelers

At Middleton Jewelers, we don’t just offer to buy, sell or trade jewelry for our customers. You can also choose any one of the following and we guarantee that you will be completely satisfied:

  • Expert Appraisals
  • Ring sizing
  • Stone replacement
  • Prong re-tipping
  • Bracelet and necklace repair
  • Jewelry mounting
  • Custom jewelry design
  • Jewelry cleaning
  • Jewelry polishing
  • Pearl restringing

Buy, Sell, Trade, or Just Get an Appraisal

No matter what your jewelry needs may be, you can trust us to handle them for you. Your happiness with your jewelry purchases or services is our best reward. Let us show you what a real professional jeweler can do for you, whether you’re buying, selling, trading or getting an appraisal. Just leave all of your jewelry needs to us and rest assured that you are always getting the very best in sales and service at Middleton Jewelers.